St. James Theatre

176 2nd Street,
St. James, NY 11780

Unfavorite No one has favorited this theater yet

Additional Info

Previously operated by: Calderone Theatres

Functions: Office Space

Nearby Theaters

St. James Theatre

Ground was broken for this, the third venue in town to bear the St. James name, on April 2, 1929. The 35 x 90 stucco, fireproof structure was built at a cost of $25,000 for John Brennan by Westerbeke Builders of West Sayville. Henry Kost, operator of the Sayville Theatre, leased the property for five years to expand his theatrical interests. The St. James Theatre is located one block east of the main north-south artery, Lake Avenue, around the corner from the first original St. James Theatre, which still stands, and which dates back to the first decade of the 20th century.

At some point this St. James Theatre was taken over by the Calderone Circuit. The St. James Theatre was still open in January 1951, but closed soon after. It is currently used for office space.

Contributed by rvb

Recent comments (view all 27 comments)

robboehm on April 2, 2014 at 11:01 am

According to the Smithtown Messenger “Johnnie Brennan’s” theatre opened October 1, 1929. At a reported cost of $ 25,000 the 30 x 90 stucco building was intended as a venue for vaudeville and films. At opening it was called The Little Playhouse at St. James and under a five year lease to Henry Kost who operated theatres in Sayville and Patchogue.

robboehm on November 16, 2014 at 6:51 pm

Added current photos of the exterior and interior. A second floor office space was created and the original ceiling supports boxed in. I don’t know what they looked like originally. The detail of the ceiling has been carefully recreated.

robboehm on September 2, 2015 at 7:41 am

Early aerial photo shows the theater in the upper left. The original St. James, still standing is on the left side of the main road, Lake Avenue at about 2 o'clock.

robboehm on September 15, 2015 at 5:53 pm

Try as I might I can’t locate a picture from the day. But, as I’ve tried to enlarge the aerial photo it appears as though there was some sort of marquee.

jackader on January 21, 2018 at 8:27 am

jackader I currently work in the building and would like to clarify. The owner since 1985 is Natalie Weinstein a noted Long Island interior designer. It is currently the home of Uniquely Natalie a quaility furniture consignment store. Secondly Natalie is the founder of Celebrate St.James – Past – Present – Future. A not for profit whose mission is to preserve and celebrate St. James history and inspire an appreciation and knowledge of the arts of our great town We would be very greatful to anyone who can provide us with pictures and information about the History of this theater. Especially regarding live vaudeville performaces. We are already in possession of playbill from the early 1940’s when it was the calderone movie theater. Thank you

robboehm on January 21, 2018 at 9:55 am

It is my understanding that before Natalie purchased the property it had been used as a garage. I remember reading that when she was doing renovations she came upon the old bathrooms. It took major digging to get the minimal information which appears on this site even going through the historical society. The second floor of Natalie’s property on Lake was the site of the original St. James Theater.

robboehm on January 20, 2019 at 3:58 pm

Newsday Classic Edition for January 23, 1951 arrived today. According to the Movie Timetable the St. James was still open then. The movie, The West Point Story with two evening performances.

robboehm on March 26, 2019 at 7:16 pm

Uploaded a recent photo of the facade.

robboehm on February 23, 2023 at 11:59 am

Due to Covid and what it had done to her business Natalie offered up the building for sale in 2021. There is now an active campaign to save the theatre and repurpose it as a cultural arts center.

robboehm on March 9, 2023 at 7:20 am

“Save the St. James Theatre”, now in its second year, has revved up its campaign by getting coverage from the primary Long Island TV channel.

You must login before making a comment.

New Comment

Subscribe Want to be emailed when a new comment is posted about this theater?
Just login to your account and subscribe to this theater.