If this really was in the high school auditorium, the address must be 608 C St. I’m a little dubious, because the auditorium was the newest building of the complex before the rest of it was demolished, and has sort of a WPA look to it. The ‘newest’ Sanborn map, from 1918, shows only a smaller old school nearer the corner of 6th and D. There was then no gym or auditorium. The older building was later cut down to one story, and is still visible on the satellite view and the 2013 streetview. As I said, today’s visit revealed that everything has been torn down but the auditorium, which is now in really awful shape. I’ll provide a picture, and maybe someone will have more definite information.
I think the address must have been 106. Downtown is totally trashed, and so many buildings are missing that it’s hard to count lots, but the 1918 Sanborn shows a one story tile brick structure with a tin cornice showing ‘moving pictures’. It would have been the fourth building south of C St, on the east side. That lot was partially occupied by a little wooden bandstand on the 1909 map. The location today is a gravel lot used as storage by a hardware store.
By the way, there’s a typo in the AKAs, ‘Sliver’ for Silver.
This will have to be marked as demolished. The spectacular bank building is nowhere to be seen. This must be the 600 block, east side, where the dumpy one-story thing is today. Address was likely 604 or thereabouts.
One of those names at least must be an AKA for the opera house. I didn’t see a third theater anywhere on the maps, and downtown really isn’t that large.
1914 Sanborn shows that the original building was a one-story structure, which appears to be slightly wider than the current building. It appears that the eastern wall may have slanted slightly outward toward the rear, as the building was then along the banks of the canal, which has been filled in in this area. The 1933 map shows a large rectangular awning/marquee. 2 internal hydrants supplied with 200' of 2" hose are noted as ‘attended’, but I guess they didn’t help.
The very blurry picture only shows a little annex on the side. The main building is just to the left of this, and has a rather bland fake old facade. 94 seems absurdly small, but appears to be correct from pictures of the auditorium. Looks like it closed around 1955, and reopened sometime after 1996 after various other uses.
Sorry, slight typo, it’s the 1925 map that shows it as a store. Not that it’s really important, but the garage door seems to have been added by 1937, when this space had become what must have been a really tiny dealership.
SethG
commented about
Town Hallon
Jul 24, 2020 at 1:27 pm
John Fryberger of the Toledo-based Spitzer and Co. was the architect for this structure.
Not that I think the address is correct, but on the off chance that it fell between the 1920-1940 gap in maps, I’ve added a 2015 picture of the Fisher Block. The ground floor has been run together with half of the neighboring building, and it is a Hallmark store.
I’m not sure why this is described as being small. The theater was huge, or at least the structure was. It was three stories tall, fairly wide, and ran the entire depth of the lot to the alley. The auditorium and stage were about 2/3 of that depth. An elaborately curved balcony, rather like a lyre in shape, appears up to the 1940 map (when it is noted that the rear wall is cracked). There was a long, wide central hallway leading between two storefronts to what appears to be a two-story lobby. The upper two floors of the front section were variously used as a hotel, offices, apartments, and a fraternal hall.
Found a bad copy of the 1940 update of the 1931 map, and it appears that at the very least, the theater was a substantial remodel of the old building. The central wall and stair are gone, although the height of the building and the footprint are identical. Still has the addresses 234-236.
The Rosenbush Block was constructed sometime between 1901 and 1911. The 1920 map shows 236, then the western portion, as a barber shop. The central stair is gone, and the entire building seems to be using the 236 address. The map marker is several blocks too far to the west.
The Miami was not in the Kerr Block, which is 202-208 N Columbia. It was in the J.A. Rosenbush Block, which was at 234-236 W Pearl. The building still exists, with a disgusting modern facade perhaps from around 1960. It appears to perhaps be depressing apartments. The structure has all the charm of a prefab building at a Soviet mining camp.
If the address is right, which is always a dubious proposition, then this has not been demolished. 237 was historically the southern storefront of the Fisher Block. It appears as though a building of two storefronts was constructed sometime before 1885, and the northern half of that was then unified with a new building on the corner by 1890. Trying to line up what seem to be 3-4 buildings with two fronts is a bit confusing, but 237 on the 1920 map is a grocery store one down from the corner. This building is now all one unit with an address of 239. The park seems to be where 227 and 229 were. The NRHP listing for downtown is exceptionally poor for a recent effort, and has almost no information about all but a select few structures. Most of the little information there is is very vague.
Actually, it seems that the address should be 115. The NRHP listing dates that structure to 1924, so the organ must have been installed during construction. The building is offices. In the blurry postcard above, it was hard to tell what building had the Lyric sign on it.
If this really was in the high school auditorium, the address must be 608 C St. I’m a little dubious, because the auditorium was the newest building of the complex before the rest of it was demolished, and has sort of a WPA look to it. The ‘newest’ Sanborn map, from 1918, shows only a smaller old school nearer the corner of 6th and D. There was then no gym or auditorium. The older building was later cut down to one story, and is still visible on the satellite view and the 2013 streetview. As I said, today’s visit revealed that everything has been torn down but the auditorium, which is now in really awful shape. I’ll provide a picture, and maybe someone will have more definite information.
I think the address must have been 106. Downtown is totally trashed, and so many buildings are missing that it’s hard to count lots, but the 1918 Sanborn shows a one story tile brick structure with a tin cornice showing ‘moving pictures’. It would have been the fourth building south of C St, on the east side. That lot was partially occupied by a little wooden bandstand on the 1909 map. The location today is a gravel lot used as storage by a hardware store.
By the way, there’s a typo in the AKAs, ‘Sliver’ for Silver.
These sort of contributions are useless.
This will have to be marked as demolished. The spectacular bank building is nowhere to be seen. This must be the 600 block, east side, where the dumpy one-story thing is today. Address was likely 604 or thereabouts.
One of those names at least must be an AKA for the opera house. I didn’t see a third theater anywhere on the maps, and downtown really isn’t that large.
1914 Sanborn shows that the original building was a one-story structure, which appears to be slightly wider than the current building. It appears that the eastern wall may have slanted slightly outward toward the rear, as the building was then along the banks of the canal, which has been filled in in this area. The 1933 map shows a large rectangular awning/marquee. 2 internal hydrants supplied with 200' of 2" hose are noted as ‘attended’, but I guess they didn’t help.
The very blurry picture only shows a little annex on the side. The main building is just to the left of this, and has a rather bland fake old facade. 94 seems absurdly small, but appears to be correct from pictures of the auditorium. Looks like it closed around 1955, and reopened sometime after 1996 after various other uses.
Sorry, slight typo, it’s the 1925 map that shows it as a store. Not that it’s really important, but the garage door seems to have been added by 1937, when this space had become what must have been a really tiny dealership.
John Fryberger of the Toledo-based Spitzer and Co. was the architect for this structure.
Added a shot of downtown in which the Star can just barely be seen.
Added a picture of the Kerr Block, in which can be seen (on the right side) the nasty facade of what was the Rosenbush Block, later the Miami.
Added a picture of the Kerr Block in which the repellent Miami appears at right.
Stupidly neglected to get a picture of this building, which has a certain scabby charm.
Not that I think the address is correct, but on the off chance that it fell between the 1920-1940 gap in maps, I’ve added a 2015 picture of the Fisher Block. The ground floor has been run together with half of the neighboring building, and it is a Hallmark store.
This building later became the Miami, using the 236 address which originally belonged to the western half.
Ohio has a poor copy of the 1940 update to the 1931 Sanborn, which shows this as a store with a lodge room above.
Ohio has a poor copy of the 1940 update to the 1931 Sanborn, which shows this as a store.
The Ohio library has a rather poor copy of the 1931 map, updated for 1940. No theater is shown anywhere on N Columbia. 237 is still a store.
I’m not sure why this is described as being small. The theater was huge, or at least the structure was. It was three stories tall, fairly wide, and ran the entire depth of the lot to the alley. The auditorium and stage were about 2/3 of that depth. An elaborately curved balcony, rather like a lyre in shape, appears up to the 1940 map (when it is noted that the rear wall is cracked). There was a long, wide central hallway leading between two storefronts to what appears to be a two-story lobby. The upper two floors of the front section were variously used as a hotel, offices, apartments, and a fraternal hall.
Found a bad copy of the 1940 update of the 1931 map, and it appears that at the very least, the theater was a substantial remodel of the old building. The central wall and stair are gone, although the height of the building and the footprint are identical. Still has the addresses 234-236.
The Rosenbush Block was constructed sometime between 1901 and 1911. The 1920 map shows 236, then the western portion, as a barber shop. The central stair is gone, and the entire building seems to be using the 236 address. The map marker is several blocks too far to the west.
The Miami was not in the Kerr Block, which is 202-208 N Columbia. It was in the J.A. Rosenbush Block, which was at 234-236 W Pearl. The building still exists, with a disgusting modern facade perhaps from around 1960. It appears to perhaps be depressing apartments. The structure has all the charm of a prefab building at a Soviet mining camp.
If the address is right, which is always a dubious proposition, then this has not been demolished. 237 was historically the southern storefront of the Fisher Block. It appears as though a building of two storefronts was constructed sometime before 1885, and the northern half of that was then unified with a new building on the corner by 1890. Trying to line up what seem to be 3-4 buildings with two fronts is a bit confusing, but 237 on the 1920 map is a grocery store one down from the corner. This building is now all one unit with an address of 239. The park seems to be where 227 and 229 were. The NRHP listing for downtown is exceptionally poor for a recent effort, and has almost no information about all but a select few structures. Most of the little information there is is very vague.
Actually, it seems that the address should be 115. The NRHP listing dates that structure to 1924, so the organ must have been installed during construction. The building is offices. In the blurry postcard above, it was hard to tell what building had the Lyric sign on it.
You didn’t give me time to get to this one! ;)