Shaw-Hayden Theatre

1381 Hayden Avenue,
Cleveland, OH 44112

Unfavorite 1 person favorited this theater

Showing 14 comments

Erieside on October 1, 2017 at 3:41 am

So Google says 1.1 mile from my old house on E 146 to the shaw- hayden show. I would have sworn it was 5 miles!

Erieside on October 1, 2017 at 3:35 am

My mother and two aunts worked at the Sussex fish and chips restaurant on hayden before it moved to wickliffe. I remember the name Nelsons restaurant but can’t picture it. I also remember how huge Shaw pool seemed but we didn’t go there much because it was a long walk home to E.146th after hours of swimming. Exactly where was Shaw pool? I’d like to Google what the distance was. I also remember the comedy and tragedy masks lit in purple at the shaw- hayden theatre and the dairy on hayden. Also on hayden was the world’s best pizza, Demarcos. Demarcos moved to Mayfield and when they closed that was the end of the world’s best.

smorchak on June 18, 2016 at 12:42 am

I loved Shaw Pool! The playground behind the fire station was enormous! I have great memories of East Cleveland. We even walked to Forest Hill Park from Hayden Avenue.

Sonworshipper on June 17, 2016 at 4:08 pm

Yes, Mary’s Sweet Shoppe, got the name wrong…does anyone remember the playground with Saturday Sandbox contests behind the fire Station and Shaw pool??..The dances above the pool on the weekends?…I counted the 57 Chevy’s coming down Shaw on Saturday nights listening to Cathy’s Clown on my new red transistor radio…♥

Sonworshipper on June 17, 2016 at 4:03 pm

Sonworshipper on June 17, 2016 at 1:58 pm (remove) Hi all…I lived in East Cleveland on Shaw Ave during the 50’ was awesome living there…yu wouldn’t recognize it now which is so sad….tree lined streets, so clean and went to the old Chambers Elementary School, the beautiful one they tore down….on Saturdays we would go to the Shaw Hayden Theatre, get a movie, cartoons and a newsreel for a quarter….before the movie they would have some kind of contest for prizes, I remember winning 2,000 sheets of paper….lol…those were great days and Mary’s Kitchen was next door where you could buy penny candy….their rock candy was always my favorite…..candy bars in the theatre was always a nickel, cokes a dime and popcorn was 15 cents….I love this picture above bc it brings back so many great memories of living there…we moved in 1961 to Mentor, Ohio and left all of that behind but it lives in my heart and memories to this very day….I loved growing up there…♥ ♥

smorchak on November 11, 2014 at 8:20 pm

My family lived on Hartford Road off Hayden and we use to walk to the Shaw-Hayden. I remember there were 2 large masks on both walls in the theatre of comedy & tragedy. They were backlit with purple lights.Great memories!

Joe Vogel
Joe Vogel on July 16, 2014 at 12:49 pm

Here is a bit more in formation about the Shaw-Hayden Theatre, from the “Contracts Awarded” column of the August 9, 1919, issue of The American Contractor:

“M. P. Theater & 4 Stores & Lodge Room: $100,000. 3 sty. 110x114. Hayden av. nr. Shaw av., East Cleveland, O. Archt. W. S. Ferguson, 1900 Euclid bldg., Cleveland. Owner Shaw Hayden Amusement Co., J. F. Bruce, pres., 315 Ardenall av., East Cleveland. Gen. Contr. J. E. Chrustlan Co., 1307 St. Clair av., Cleveland. Mas. & carp, by gen. contr. Htg. let to Martin Elec. Co., Illuminating bldg., Cleveland. 1st sty. mas.”
Architect William Stanley Ferguson designed at least three other theaters in the Cleveland area.

Yo on July 16, 2014 at 10:37 am

Enjoyed this comment: My husband was a projectionist at the Shaw-Hayden and I would walk from the corner where our apartment was to go see movies on the nights he worked (probably free).I remember going to a “Nelson’s” restaurant but didn’t know it was there. No one I know remembers it. Also, yes Sussex fish was a favorite too but do not remember it being in the Shaw/Hayden neighborhood. I know it is now on Euclid Ave. Shaw/Hayden was another one of those great middle class neighborhoods; There was Shaw High School and Shaw Stadium.

Bob44c on July 22, 2013 at 12:01 am

The news today on national news tells of a serial killer who had several bodies right around the corner from the old Shaw-Hayden. I knew that area well though I grew up in South Euclid. Just across the street and closer to Shaw there was a restaurant named Nelsons where my parents had their wedding reception when they were married on June 27, 1936. Driving to my grandparents home on Paxton in Cleveland, many times we would see the Shaw-Hayden. In addition on Hayden I remember Susex Fish and Chips which was a little further north on Hayden. Although I don’t remember seeing a movie at the Shaw-Hayden though I may have when I was really young, I wonder if there were any pictures of the inside of that famed theater? I know one thing is for certain and that is that they “didn’t build them like they use to” which was the case for Shaw-Hayden.

Joe Vogel
Joe Vogel on December 26, 2011 at 6:09 am

The November 15, 1919, issue of trade journal Motion Picture News had this item in its section on Cleveland:

:“The Shaw-Hayden, also a 1200 seat photoplay house opened its doors to the public for the first time October 25. The Shaw-Hayden is the biggest neighborhood theatre to be built on the East Side. Nothing has been spared to make it complete both in structure, equipment, decorations or program. J. J. Mellert, who also runs the Fulton theatre, Cleveland, is manager of the new Shaw-Hayden.”

kencmcintyre on February 18, 2010 at 8:11 pm

Here is an ad for some horror movies circa 1965:

CSWalczak on April 8, 2009 at 1:20 am

Two pictures of the Shaw-Hayden:
View link

View link

shamrock on December 4, 2007 at 7:47 am

I rememebr seeing Mary Poppins there in the early 1960’s. The store next door was called Mary’s Sweet Shop. I remember buying my refreshments there.

Dan1512 on June 24, 2007 at 4:27 pm

Remeber going to the Saturday afternoon movies. All the kids had a membership card. A three diget number could get you the grand prize at a drawing. Single number could get free candy or even admission. I got a free admission once and did’t tell my mother. Used the extra money for more snacks. Remeber a candy store or something like that next to the theater. We bought popcorn there and was allowed to take it into the movie.